Many of you have been asking for a soy and coconut-free yogurt recipe. After using 6 pounds of almonds for testing, here it is!
This yogurt is thick, creamy, slightly tart and made with 100% homemade almond milk! I didn’t want to go with cashews here simply because it would have made the yogurts too heavy, and I wanted something light. Almonds are great but there was one problem, when making yogurt from almond milk, it never thickens.
So after checking the ingredient list of tens of vegan yogurts and reading reviews about it, I started to work with thickeners.
I first went with pectin, but it’s a bit messy to work with and I was not getting a satisfying texture. In the end, I went with a mix of three thickeners: locust bean gum also known as carob bean gum, xanthan gum and a pinch of agar-agar. When combined together, they form a gel, it’s science so don’t ask me how it works exactly! The main point is that it results in a thick and creamy yogurt. Xanthan gum helps thicken everything a bit more and improves the mouthfeel while agar prevents the yogurts from having a slimy texture.
I use a very small amount of agar here (1/32 tsp) because it’s very powerful and you don’t want to get a flan or jelly yogurt texture!
HEALTH BENEFITS
Yogurts are packed with good live bacterias, known as probiotics. They help boost the immune system and improve digestion. Since these yogurts are made from 100% almonds, they are naturally soy-free, refined sugar-free, dairy-free and gluten-free!
HOW TO MAKE VEGAN ALMOND MILK YOGURT
Before starting: Please don’t try to substitute or omit any ingredient here, it took a lot of tests to get this recipe right and just a small change will affect the texture of the yogurt. For example, when using cornstarch or arrowroot, the yogurts have a slimy texture, so stick to locust bean gum. If using too much xanthan gum, the yogurts tend to be gelatinous, etc… Don’t be scared by this recipe, it’s actually very easy!
You will need 5 ingredients to make your own almond milk yogurts:
- Almonds
- Locust Bean Gum
- Xanthan Gum
- Agar Agar
- Yogurt Starter (or non-dairy yogurt)
- Optional: vanilla bean or vanilla extract, maple syrup
Alright, let’s do it! We will first prepare the almond milk because we are going to do everything from scratch. Start by soaking the almonds for at least 6 hours, preferably overnight. I tried with roasted almonds but the flavor was bitter, so only use raw almonds. You can use blanched or whole almonds, it doesn’t really matter.
Once your almonds have soaked for several hours, drain them and place in a blender with the filtered water. Blend on high speed until smooth, about 30-40 seconds. For exact quantities please check the recipe at the end of this post. You can then strain the almond milk using a nut milk bag, just squeeze the bag to release the milk. Almond pulp can be discarded or saved for other recipes. Your milk is ready to use, now comes the easiest part, making the yogurts!
Combine your freshly made almond milk with the locust bean gum, xanthan gum and agar agar in a saucepan and whisk until everything is well combined. Then heat to 185°F (85°C) to activate the gums and agar. Remove from heat and let cool.
Once it reaches 110°F (43°C), stir in the yogurt starter, or 3 tbsp non-dairy yogurt and whisk. I used only half a packet of this starter since one packet is given for 4 cups milk. Be aware the almond milk will need to be churned as it will have already thickened a bit, this is normal. So whisk well to break any possible lumps and make the texture smooth again.
You can now pour into glass jars and let the yogurts culture for 5-6 hours at 105-115°F (40-45°C). If you don’t have a yogurt maker, you can use your oven. Place the jars in a dish filled with warm water and put in the oven with the light on, or set at 105°F for 5 hours. It’s the technique I used and it worked great!
After 6 hours, place the yogurts in the refrigerator for at least 8 hours. Your yogurts are now ready! These make a tasty and fresh breakfast. Top with granola, fresh fruits, a drizzle of maple syrup and some nut butter for healthy fats!
If you plan to make these regularly, make sure to save 3 tbsp of yogurt for the next batch.
GREEK-STYLE
This yogurt is already thick, but if you want an even thicker yogurt, you can get a greek-style yogurt consistency by draining the whey from the yogurts. To do that, line a fine mesh strainer with a cheesecloth, pour the yogurt into it. Let the strainer rest on top of a bowl to catch excess liquid and place in the refrigerator for 1-2 hours. After one hour, your yogurt should already be thicker, let it rest longer for a thicker texture.
FLAVORS
Now for those of you who don’t like plain yogurt, I’m sharing 7 variants (not all pictured) to flavor your yogurts. Commercial yogurts almost always contain added flavorings and a lot of sugar, by making your own you know exactly what’s in there.
- Blueberry: Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with 1/4 cup homemade blueberry jam. I recommend checking Bakerita’s Blueberry Chia Jam recipe for a low sugar version.
- Peach: Purée 1 large peach with 2 tsp maple syrup. Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with the peach purée.
- Salted Caramel Crunch: In a small bowl, mix 1 tbsp almond butter with 1 tbsp maple syrup and 1/8 tsp salt. Stir the caramel into 1/2 cup yogurt and top with roasted pecans.
- Amaretto: Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with 1/4 cup cherry jam and 1/8 tsp almond extract.
- Nutella: Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with 2 tbsp hazelnut butter, 2 tbsp cocoa powder, and 2 tbsp maple syrup.
- Key Lime: Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with 2 tbsp lime juice. Sweeten to taste.
- Double Chocolate: Mix 1/2 cup yogurt with 2 tbsp cocoa powder, 1 tbsp maple syrup (or more, to taste) and 1 tbsp chocolate chips.
For those of you who prefer it plain, you can simply sweeten it with a drizzle of maple syrup, coconut nectar or even stevia.
If you are looking for a soy-free, coconut-free yogurt, this is it. It’s creamy, smooth and has the perfect texture! Let me know in the comments if you try this recipe and what is your favorite flavor!
Vegan Almond Milk Yogurt
Smooth and creamy homemade yogurt made from almond milk. Healthy, packed with good bacterias and easy to make!
Yield: 4 Yogurts (5.3oz)
Print Recipe
Pin RecipeIngredients
Almond Milk
- 1 cup (140g) raw almonds
- 3 cups (750ml) filtered water
Yogurts
- 2 and 1/2 cup homemade almond milk
- 1 tsp locust bean gum
- 1/4 tsp xanthan gum
- 1/32 tsp agar agar (see notes)
- 1 yogurt starter (or 2 tbsp non-dairy yogurt) I used half a packet of this starter.
- Optional: 2 tsp maple syrup, seeds from 1/2 vanilla bean (or 1/4 tsp vanilla extract)
Instructions
Almond Milk
- Soak the almonds for at least 6 hours, or overnight. Drain and add to a blender with the 3 cups of water. Blend on high-speed for 30-40 seconds, until smooth.
- Place a nut milk bag over a large glass bowl. Pour the almond milk into the bag and twist to close. Using your hands, squeeze to extract as much almond milk as possible. You should end up with about 2 and 1/2 cup of almond milk.
Yogurts
- Combine the almond milk (2 and 1/2 cups), locust bean gum, xanthan gum, and agar in a medium saucepan. If you want to make a sweetened yogurt, also add the maple syrup and vanilla seeds. Heat over medium heat until it reaches 185°F (85°C), whisking constantly to make sure all the gums are fully dissolved and don’t stay at the bottom. Remove from heat at soon as it reaches 185°F, just before it boils. Transfer to a large glass bowl and let sit for about 20 minutes, or until the temperature reaches 110°F (43°c). This is important, if the milk is too hot it will kill the cultures. Using a thermometer is strongly recommended.
- Once the milk is at the right temperature, stir in the yogurt starter. At this step, the almond milk will have already thickened and may appear gelatinous, don’t worry this is totally normal. Give it a good whisk to break any “lumps”, and make it fully smooth again. Pour into glass jars and close the lid, or use plastic wrap to cover.
- Place the jars in a baking dish filled with warm water, they should be half immersed. If you have a yogurt maker, skip this step and just put the jars into your machine.
- Place the baking dish with the jars in a 105°F preheated oven for 6-10 hours depending on how sour you like your yogurts. Personally, I prefer them with a milder flavor so I let them culture for only 6 hours.
- Transfer the yogurts to the refrigerator and let cool for at least 8 hours.
- Enjoy for breakfast or dessert, sweetened with some maple syrup and topped with granola, fresh fruits, jam or nut butter. Always give the yogurts a good stir before eating!
- The yogurts will keep for up to 4 days in the refrigerator.
Notes
Agar agar is very powerful so only 1/32 tsp is enough for about 3 cups almond milk. To measure 1/32 tsp, fill one-half of a 1/8 tsp. Using the tip of a knife, remove half of it to get 1/32 tsp.
This recipe might work with store-bought almond milk but I haven’t tried yet.
If you don’t have yogurt starter or non-dairy yogurt, you can also use probiotics. For this recipe, use 3 capsules vegan probiotics.
If you plan to use this yogurt for savory dishes, omit the maple syrup and vanilla.
Nutritional information is just an estimate and may not be accurate.
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 5.3oz (150g)
- Calories: 72
- Fat: 6.6g
- Carbohydrates: 2.2g
- Fiber: 1.95g
- Protein: 2.35g
I will be making this yogurt for sure. I love greek style yogurt and I’m trying to cut dairy products from my diet and I was wondering how I will substitute the greek yogurt. Thank you
Just noticed that I have all of the ingredients at home. So I better soak some almonds now!
Can psyllium powder be substituted and in the same amount for xanthan gum? Thank you.
I have absolutely no idea, sorry! But if you try it I would love to hear how it went!
I wonder if you can make in a Instant Pot? Thanks so much for sharing.
I made it in my instant pot, but only the stage two curing. Did the stove top for stage 1
Hi Thomas.
I’ve been looking everywhere for locust bean gum, but can’t find it in my country plus no shipping here from Amazon. Can it be replaced with other thing?….
Blessings and can’t wait for you next surprise :))
Best yogurt I ever had, better than the one made with dairy!
Thank you Thomas,
France
I made this recipe as written and it was great! I’m curious about the need for all the different thickeners and whether heating to 185F is necessary for the thickeners to activate or for pasteurization. Thanks so much! The yogurt was delicious!
This recipe required a lot of tests and I always got the best results by using this mix of thickeners. However, I’m working on an updated recipe that will require fewer ingredients, stay tuned!
Glad to hear you liked the yogurt 😉
I have only the zantham gum and agar agar.
I know it’s an exact science but if you could guess, how much of the xantham gum should I use because I dont have locust bean?
I won’t hold you to it if it doesn’t turn out as good.
Thank you
I love this site.
I appreciate your time and talents!
That’s a tough question…I would say try to increase the xanthan gum by 1/4 tsp, but I can’t guarantee the results. Locust bean gum is essential in this recipe if you want to get a creamy texture.
I’m working on another recipe that won’t require locust bean gum, stay tuned!
He’ll
I bought guar gum hoping to sub it.
I’ll let ya know
I think the hardest part for me about eating healthy and making everything at home is trying to gather up all the ingredients there so lack of where I live. It’s not always convenient for me to order online either. Again I thank you for your expertise here I have tried several recipes and all of them were wonderful my blue cheese just turned blue a few days ago and I’m delighted.
Thank you for everything!
So happy to hear the blue mold is starting to appear on your cheese! Exciting right?
I hope you will like the yogurt recipe as well 🙂
Making the yogurt now 🙂
Interesting things happen in the kitchen (you understand this well lol)
I made the yogurt and when I went to add the cultures they were a funny yellow color and didn’t mix with the milk well. I put everything in my vitamin and blended it, It was frothy :-(. So I added a bit more milk.
I have a feeling the cultures are bad…I will out soon. I hate wasting.
Humm…I guess you cultures were too old, it shouldn’t color the milk and should dissolve well.
Hey Thomas — you still working on the updated yogurt recipe? Would love to hear how that’s going!
On and off, the results are not satisfying enough to share yet, sorry Matt!
I would really like to try this recipe, but my oven does not go down to 105. Its lowest setting is 170. Can I use my dehydrator and if so, what temp. Thank-you for your help. Suzie
Hey Suzie, the best temperature to incubate yogurts is between 105-112°F, so you should be able to use your dehydrator with no problem. If you need an exact temperature I would recommend 109°F.
try your crock pot on a low setting and if it to hot crack the lid
Hello!
It looks like a great recipe!
Should I add some sugar, so that the starter works better, or is sugar necessary if using probiotic capsules?
Thank you
Georgia
★★★★★
Hi Georgia,
Sugar is not necessary, I have made many batches without it and it always worked great. I think there are natural sugars in almonds.
I was wondering whether I could skip straining the almond milk if I blanch the almonds to remove the skins and then blend them at high speed in my Vitamix? I do this when making an almond sauce and t is smooth and creamy.
Yes, you can skip the straining step if you do that. I also have a powerful blender but to me, it’s still slightly gritty if I don’t strain it.
Hello again!
Can I use any probiotic For my yogurt or does it need to be the specific one you recommend? I also may have cultures from cultures for health in my cupboard so that will work well.
Looking forward to making the Greek version as I like thick and creamy!
Trying guar gum as I could not find locust bean anywhere.
Thank you again.
D
Hey Debra,
I won’t recommend using any probiotics, some won’t yield good results. It’s safer to go with yogurt cultures or use some vegan yogurt as a starter.
I’ll be giving this another try. By the way, I did use the guar gum and zantham gums and the consistency was perfect! Before I blended it and ruined it anyway…lol
Can you freeze the yogurt for frozen yogurt as an option after the four days? I can’t wait to try this recipe!
★★★★★
I have no idea! I have never tried but I don’t think that would work, you would probably need to add some sugar and fat (cashew cream maybe?) to make it scoopable right from the freezer, otherwise it will be very hard.
Wow. This almond milk yogurt looks incredible! Any chance you have instructions on making it in an Instant Pot?
Love your blog. I, too, am virtually acne-free – for the first time in 40+ years – since eliminating dairy (which, apparently, I’m actually very allergic to). Thanks for all the great dairy-free recipes (can’t wait to try the cheeses)!
Thanks Cheryl! I don’t have instructions to make it in the Instant Pot yet but I think it’s pretty easy. Pour 1 cup of water into the liner and place the steamer rack on top. Then transfer the yogurt to jars and place them on the steamer rack. Cover with a lid and set it on Yogurt mode (on normal) for 7-8 hours.
Glad to hear I’m not the only one who saw huge benefits by going dairy-free 🙂
Hey Thomas,
Great non diary yogurt recipe can you please give us sugar content in 1 cup. I can’t have regular plain whole milk yogurt because it has 10 gms of sugar in 1cup.
Thanks.
Raj.
★★★★★
Hey Raj,
There is no added sugar, you may find some sugar from the almonds but that’s all. It’s probably less than a gram per cup.
Morning Thomas,
Thanks for info on almond yogurt, I have ordered agar agar, xanthan gum ,locust bean gum and mini measuring kit from amazon. So I have two questions, can you use almond milk made from home made almond butter in vitamix, usually make 3 cups raw almond butter and use 1 tbsp for 1 cup of milk. This way there is no left over stuff.
Secondly, I have been using my cuisinart electric yogurt maker for regular cow’s milk, now I can’t because of sugar spike in glucose levels. The container for this machine has a capacity of 50 oz, little more than 6 cups. Your recipe is for 2 1/2 cups, I would like to double it to 5 cups. So will it be OK to double your recipe also.
Good day,
Thanks,
Raj.
★★★★★
Hi Raj,
I doubt it will work, I never heard of almond milk made from almond butter honestly. I don’t think it’s as rich as one made from whole almonds blended with water, and the consistency is probably a bit different. But if you try it let me know!
Yes, it’s totally okay to double the recipe!
I made this with store bought unsweetened vanilla almond milk and it came out amazing! love the salted caramel crunch and double chocolate.
★★★★★
oh and i made it in my instant pot for 6 hours! 🙂
Thanks for your feedback Melissa! I’m so glad to hear you liked the yogurt. It’s also interesting to hear that it worked with store-bought almond milk!
Hi Melissa,
Wondering, which store brand did you buy, I followed Thomas recipe first to make almond milk and then set yogurt.
Thanks,
Raj.
★★★★★
What brand of milk did you use?
Hi Thomas,
Success, very first time, followed your instructions and great consistency, hardly any whey, very thick and delicious. No need to strain and I’m sticking with this yogurt, I topped with 1tbsp sugarfree blueberry preserve.
I have saved 3tbsp of this yogurt for next batch, so just to make sure I get it right, I’ll follow the recipe as is and at 110°F add 3 tbsp of saved yogurt. ..right. And this time I’ll make 4 cups of almond milk.
Please advise if any changes to be made.
Thanks,
Raj.
Great! 🙂
That is correct, if you are making about 4 cups of yogurt, add 3 tbsp of your old yogurt at around 110°F. 2 tbsp would probably be enough actually.
Hello again!
I am making this yogurt this afternoon.
How many ml’s are each cup of milk you are using?
Because the culture I have asks for millilitres.
Thank you
So 1 cup equals about 236 ml.
Hello!
I finally made the yogurts yesterday.
The texture was very creamy and milky.
For 500 gr homemade almond milk, I used 1/2 packet of this starter: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Starter-culture-for-Original-Bulgarian-natural-home-Yogurt-Yoghurt-for-5-or-10-l/262832676291?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&var=561830910891&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649.
The only thing is that I would prefer my yogurt to be more sour, but I belive this is a matter of the yogurt starter.
Perhaps, I shall use more quantity for my next batch.
The combination of the thickeners used in this recipe is great, the best of all I have used so far.
Thank you
Hi Georgia,
I’m glad to hear you liked the texture of the yogurts! The thickeners are not super easy to find but I really think this combination yields a good consistency.
If I can give you one advice, do not increase the amount of starter. It won’t make them more sour and you will probably end up with a lot of “whey”. If you want more sour yogurts: use a teaspoon of your favorite yogurt as the starter and/or increase the incubation time.
Thank you Thomas!
I follow your advice for my next batch!
Congrats as well, for your fantastic toppings!
★★★★★
Hello again Thomas!
I raised the incubation time to 11 hours and the taste is amazing!
One more question.
If i wanted to have a thicker yogurt,what could I do?I read what you write about greek style yogurt,but mine has no whey i guess.
So,what if i raised the amount of agar agar?whould it thicken the yogurt at all?
Thank you again for the great recipe.
★★★★★
Great! 🙂 By increasing the amount of agar you will probably end up with a texture a bit more gelatinous. Maybe try increasing a bit the xanthan gum.
Would you clarify what a “nut milk bag” is? Where might one get one? Could you post a photo of this part of the process?
Thanks so much!!!!
A nut milk bag is a tissue bag used to strain the milk from the pulp. You can find it on Amazon: http://a.co/iC60pHC
Hello! Thank you for sharing your research and success, finally something without coconut!
I have a question: can I boil the agar and gums appart or with a small amount of almond milk, and then mix it with the rest? I would like to make raw yogurt if possible.
I was wondering also about sunflower or flaxseeds. Has anyone tried making yogurt with them?
Almond is great also because coconut is so full of saturated fat. your recipe is more ecologic and healthier!
★★★★★
Hi Léna!
You can probably boil the agar and gums with half, or a quarter of the almond milk but not less as it might thicken too much and you will have trouble mixing it with the cold almond milk after. Let me know if you try it! Personally, I have nothing against coconut, I think everything in moderation is okay.
Thank you so much for this recipe. I can’t wait to try it. How many days will this yogurt keep?
Thank you!
It will keep for up to 4 days, maybe a few more days.
Hi, do you keep the oven on for the entire 5 hours at 105?
Hi Rachel, yes that is correct! Or you can use a yogurt maker, or the Instant Pot to incubate the yogurts!
Hi! So I made this recipe yesterday and discovered that the locust bean gum never fully dissolved before it reached 180 degrees. Has this ever happened to you? While the yogurt is pleasant (LOVE that authentic almond, slight-cherry flavor), it is not super smooth. Oh, and I’ll def let it sit in the oven longer next time to make it more sour 🙂 .
★★★★
Hi Stefanie! It never happened to me, but maybe try to blend the milk with the gums in your blender first, and then heat it. That should help.
Glad to hear you like the taste though 🙂 Hope it will be smoother next time 😉
I’m completely happy with this recipe! The yogurt is better than I imagined. The instructions were great and straightforward and the recipe is relatively easy. I’m not the biggest coconut yogurt fan and was happy to find a different plant based alternative. Thanks for sharing
★★★★★
Thanks for the feedback Dewayne! Happy to hear you liked the yogurts 😉
Hi! I just made this recipe and the flavor of the yogurt was really nice, thank you so much for the info on thickeners, this is the first recipe that’s really worked for almond milk yogurt! I do have a question on consistency. My yogurt developed a thicker top layer when it was in the fridge, I mixed together before eating, but it made it a little chunky. Do you have any ideas what might have caused that? I’m not sure if the amount of yogurt started I used was off. Thank you! 🙂
★★★★★
Hi Stephanie,
Glad to hear you liked it! Did you cover the yogurts with plastic film in the fridge? I guess the top dried and formed a skin like it would on custard.
I love the detail of this recipe! thanks for explaining why you are doing each step, there are so many variations of vegan yogurt recipes I appreciate knowing your logic/science behind each step. Great explanations. I am trying this with Silk cashew milk instead of homemade, which I am hoping will work with our the addition of the gums because there are already Locust gum and several other gummy additives to that product.
You’re welcome! Honestly I’m not sure it will work with store-bought milk, tweaking this recipe is a bit complicated as I created it specifically for natural almond milk. Let me know if you try it!
Just wanted to comment that 1/2 of 1/8 is 1/16, not 1/32 so you may want to correct that. Looking forward to trying the recipe, sounds great! Have you tried doubling the ingredients?
Thanks for your input Mike, the 1/32 tsp measurement is correct. As explained in the notes, you fill half of a 1/8 tsp which equals 1/16 tsp. Then use a knife to remove half of it so you get one-quarter of 1/8 tsp which equals 1/32. This recipe can be doubled and will actually make measuring the agar easier 🙂
Can I make this in a larger amount rather than small dishes? Do you think I could make in larger mason jars? Thank you!
I think it can work, yes.
Hi, can I use guar gum instead of locust bean gum- I can’t find it in my country.
I’m afraid it won’t work the same, you could try but I can’t guarantee the results. Locust bean gum doesn’t act the same as guar gum.
Buy it online at Amazon.com. Just click the link on Thomas’ page. It’ll take you right to it.
Thomas,
after 6 failed yogurt making try I finally succeeded using your recipe. I followed all your steps and ingredients and it work beautifully. The yogurt is thick and creamy just the way i like it. thank you for the recipe…I will be making many more.
★★★★★
Hi John, six tries from this recipe?!
I’m super glad you liked the yogurt 🙂 Thanks for your feedback and rating, really appreciated.
Other recipes…I was successful with yours on my first try
I tried this the earlier in the week and the taste is okay…however the texture is very curd like. Im not sure what went wrong I followed the recipe.
Humm, that is weird, it should be smooth. Did you use the exact ingredients? Locust bean gum, etc?
I just made this following your recipe almost exactly and it came out wonderfully thick and creamy! I did leave it out a few hours longer, but will aim for 6 hours next time. I had tried to make almond yogurt once without thickeners and it was more like milk.
This is going to be a staple in my house from now on. I used to do soy yogurt but I prefer getting less soy in my foods. Thank you for posting this.
★★★★★
So glad to hear the recipe worked great for you VJ! Thanks for the feedback and rating 😉
Thomas, I’ve made the recipe about 6 times now with some variations. I just wanted to share my experiences.
1) I measured the quantities of each of the gums as follows 2 g locust bean gum + 0.5 g xanthan gum + 0.06 g agar powder. I bought a jeweler scale for the measurements and put the mix in a small bag for easy use
2) tried making a batch using 2.5 cups store bought almond milk and it came out too jelly like, probably because of the gums found in store bought almond milk
3) tried using 3 cups using your recipe and preferred this texture a bit more, personally
4) made almond milk using 2 Tbsp almond butter in 3 cups water. Strained using a nutbag. Then proceeded with your recipe. This too came out perfect.
★★★★★
Thanks for sharing VJ! I’m sure the grams will be helpful for many people here.
Yes starting with store-bought almond milk is not a good solution, you will get different results depending on the brand: ingredients used, percentage of almonds, additives, etc.
I’m curious about your last experiment though, I’ve never tried making almond milk from almond butter. Is the texture as rich as milk made from whole almonds?
Thomas,
I learned the technique of using almond butter to make milk from this video: https://youtu.be/57ZpEYjE6Wo
In the video, the cameraman liked the butter version even more.
For me, it tastes just as good!
Yes, it tastes delicious. I learned how to make it from this video. https://youtu.be/57ZpEYjE6Wo
If you watch it until the end, you’ll see the cameraman chose the butter version in a “blind” taste test compared to the traditional method.
Thanks for sharing!
Hi Thomas,
Thank you very much for posting this recipe and this is the only recipe that gives me good almond yogurt! I do have 2 questions,
1) when I use 1 cup of almond and 3 cups of water, I get more than 2.5 cups of almond mile, should I reduce the water?
2) your recipe says to heat the almond milk up to 180 F jut before it boils. When I am heating the almond milk, just before it boils, it is around 165 F. I made yogurt with 165 F because I misread the temperature. The yogurt turns out okay just the texture is a little too soft. Today I made sure it reached 185 F and it was boiling for a few minutes. What did I do wrong?
Thanks.
Hi Helen,
Great! Regarding your questions, 1) I wouldn’t reduce the water, use leftover almond milk in smoothies, oatmeal, etc. You get more or less milk depending on how much you strain the almond pulp. Sometimes I get just 2.5 cups and sometimes more. 2) It shouldn’t boil at 185°F, the boiling point is 212°F so maybe your thermometer is not perfectly accurate. Actually, you don’t really need a thermometer for that, just keep an eye on it and remove from heat as soon as you see some bubbles appearing on the sides.
This recipe works! I had given up on making almond yogurt because it never thickened. I decided to try this recipe because of the great reviews. Thank you, Thomas!
★★★★★
Glad to hear you liked it Kelly! Thanks for the feedback!
I’m anxious to try this recipe. It sounds terrific. Being a life-long fanatic about plain, unsweetened dairy yogurt, and love to make my own, the store-bought dairy-free versions available are, if nothing else, disappointing now that I am forced to be dairy-free. The texture is wrong, they are always sweetened, etc. In short: WRONG!
One question: Did you mean 1/16th teaspoon Agar Agar? Half of 1/8th is 1/16th, right? Unless you were trying to describe just taking half the tip of the 1/8th teaspoon, or 1/4 of the 1/8th teaspoon. Clarification, please.
It is 1/32 teaspoon of agar, so 1/4 of a 1/8 tsp. Agar is very powerful and if you use too much your yogurt might have a jelly texture, not something you want. That’s why I’m using so little.
If you like the consistency and flavor of the yogurt, then you can make a double batch next time so it’s easier to measure 1/16 tsp.
Hello! First time jumping into this hence would love to clarify something 🙂 I’ve actually read from many other places that it’s highly unlikely to impossible to re-culture old non-diary yoghurt and make a second batch as the cultures don’t last long in alternative yogurts. So based on your experience, how successful have you been in re-culturing old non-diary yoghurt?
Thanks!
Hey Sophie,
Humm…from my experience it is totally possible! Actually, I almost always use non-dairy yogurt as the starter now, I don’t bother buying a powdered starter. I usually just get a teaspoon from my old batch or from a store-bought soy yogurt.
Thanks so much for taking the time to reply to my queries! I did try it out using store bought non diary yogurt as a starter. The first attempt was perfect! However, when I tried to re-culture the yogurt (from first attempt) on my second attempt, the texture came out a little off! The yogurt first looked like a flan, and then when I beat it up with a whisk it had this very grainy and gritty texture. The yogurt was also more watery than on my first attempt.
I read online that it could be due to heating up the milk to 185degrees too fast, or due to the non-diary yogurt starter containing additives. May I know if you have an idea what caused the gritty yogurt?
Another question! Can the yogurt be freezed and then defrosted to be used as a starter for a new batch?
I see, what you describe is what happens when you use too much starter. How many tablespoons of yogurt starter did you use?
Regarding if the yogurt can be frozen I honestly have no idea, I never tried but I guess it should work.
I’ll try to make the Vegan Almond Milk Yogurt however, I’m not able to find in your page any measurements to mix the right amount of milk with the 3 ingredients you recommend
Locust Bean Gum
Xanthan Gum
Agar Agar
In other words, how much Locust Gum, Xanthan Gum and Agar I have to use per 1 liter of milk (US 1 qt)
Thank you for your answer
Angela, everything is written in the recipe box at the end of the article.
can I use kefir as a probiotics?
Kefir doesn’t have the same cultures as yogurt so I doubt you will get satisfying results.
Is it possible to use hazelnut milk instead of almond milk? Love the recipe, thanks for sharing
★★★★★
I think it should work! Maybe add some cocoa powder later and boom, nutella yogurt 🙂
Thanks so much for this amazing recipe! I’m going to try it out later this week. Can I ask if rejuvelac can be used instead of yogurt starter?
Hi Kristen, thanks! I wouldn’t use rejuvelac here as it’s better to start with yogurt cultures. Yogurt cultures are active at higher temperatures and yield a different flavor.
Hi!! Can I double or triple this recipe for larger batches?
Hi Avani! I have never tried to triple but don’t see why this wouldn’t work!
Looking forward to trying out this recipe! The one I have been using was from Cultures for Health and tasted fair to poor often used in shakes to disguise the flavor. My question is would using Cultures For Health Vegan Yogurt Starter dense | Non GMO, Gluten Free by Cultures For Health work for the yogurt starter? Thank you
Well, it should work well (I haven’t tried it though) but if you are not sure I would recommend buying your favorite yogurt and using a tablespoon as the starter.
Half of 1/8 tsp of agar agar is 1/16. This is twice as much as 1/32. Do you use the 1/16 tsp or actually go down to the 1/32?
Yes, half of 1/8 is 1/16. Measure that and then using the tip of a knife remove half of it to get 1/32 tsp. Or you can double the recipe if you think it’s too hard to measure.
Can l use one 50 billion probiotic pill that l use for soy yogurt? Thanks!
It really depends on what’s inside the pill, not all probiotics are suitable for yogurt making.
It’s Ultimate Flora by Renew Life. The one everyone recommends for soy yogurt.
I’m afraid I have never tried this brand, if it works on your soy yogurt then it should work on almond milk yogurt!
Just finished sampling my first batch. Soooo good!! I cultured mine for 14 hours in my Instant Pot and love the sour kick it has. I made a newbie mistake of forgetting to add the thickeners until after I heated my milk but the texture is still great. There are a few lumps due to my error, but I will iron that out in the next batch. This recipe is gold! THANK YOU!
★★★★★
Awesome! Glad to hear you liked it Jennifer!
1) I cannot find locust bean gum. My local heath food store is awesome but doesn’t carry it.
2) Can you use some regular yogurt (Fage) for the culture? That’s what I did with my dairy yogurt.
Thanks in advance!
Have you searched for it online? I’m not sure it’s easy to find in local stores. Yes you can use yogurt as a starter as explained in the recipe 😉